NAPOLEON Review — Ridley Scott and Joaquin Phoenix Reach Their Zenith

Share this:

Lisa Johnson Mandell’s Napoleon review says that director Ridley Scott has reached his apex with this intriguing examination of one of the most enigmatic and outrageous leaders of the 1700s. Joaquin Phoenix is peculiarly perfect in the lead.

Napoleon reviewI never thought I’d say this about a film, but I can’t wait for Ridley Scott’s four-plus hour director’s cut of Napoleon.

It’s such an expansive subject, and Scott’s cinematic coverage is so intriguing, that with Napoleon’s 2.5 hour runtime, I couldn’t get enough.

I’ll admit I was a bit dubious about the casting of Joaquin Phoenix as the iconic French military icon, mostly because he was reported be going with his natural American accent—he couldn’t be bothered to get an accent coach?

But with most of the cast playing Germans, French and Russians using standard Mid-Atlantic accents, authenticity was clearly not the goal. Surprisingly, the film doesn’t suffer from that. Napoleon stands alone in history, and Phoenix’s interpretation of him stands alone in film.

 

Napoleon review — Does it live up to the hype?

What Napoleon achieved in France, rising from relative Corsican obscurity to become an all-powerful commander and Emperor of France, then facing exile on a barren island only to escape and return to power again, is a quite the mercurial feat.

Punctuate that with his outrageously volatile relationship with Joséphine (played masterfully by Vanessa Kirby), and you have an epic tale to tell. If the editing leaves audiences a bit confounded, it’s understandable—there’s just so much juicy material to pack into one film.

I would suggest viewers read up on Napoleon, even if it only involves skimming the Wikipedia notes, before settling in for this riveting cinematic event—it will decrease your confusion and increase your awareness of the utter havoc one audacious man can wreak on the world.

Scott has always been both revered and skewered for his graphic and unforgettable battle scenes, and Napoleon could be the apex of them all. More than gore (although make no mistake, there’s plenty of that) they rivet attention with insights into military strategy and personal dynamics, giving them unique and fascinating dimension.

But at the core of Napoleon is his manic fascination with his lover, wife and ex Josephine. Kirby is sublimely layered, while Phoenix is creepily unhinged. It’s a portrayal of a relationship unlike any you’ve ever seen.

Which is to say that in my opinion Scott may have reached his peak with Napoleon. I can almost forgive him for the unconscionable The Last Duel. Almost…

If this Napoleon review makes you want to march down to your local cineplex, get times and tickets at Fandango.com.

Lisa Johnson Mandell’s Napoleon review says that director Ridley Scott has reached his apex with this intriguing examination of one of the most enigmatic and outrageous leaders of the 1700s. Joaquin Phoenix is peculiarly perfect in the lead.

 

Share this:

Lisa Johnson Mandell

Lisa Johnson Mandell is an award winning journalist, author and film/TV critic. She can be heard regularly on Cumulus radio stations throughout the US, and seen on Rotten Tomatoes. She is the author of three bestselling books, and spends as much of her free time as possible with her husband Jim and her jolly therapy Labradoodle Frankie Feldman.

Leave a Comment





The Latest

COYOTE VS ACME Review — The Anvils Drop, By Popular Demand

The Coyote vs Acme Movie — Fueled by Fervent Fan Furor

Critics Choice Association Reveals Honorees for the 6th Annual Celebración of Cinema and Television

MUTINY Review — Unapologetically Familiar in All the Best Ways

TONY Review — The Tasty Tale of Anthony Bourdain’s Seminal Summer of ’75

Pow! 2026 Annual CCA Super Awards Winners Announced

SPIDER-MAN BRAND NEW DAY Review — Doesn’t Stick the Landing

12 Wondrous Ways to Watch THE ODYSSEY in Theaters — Which One’s Right For You?

THE ODYSSEY Review — The Next Great Historical Epic

THE DINK Review — Can This Warm, Clever Comedy Serve Up a Win?