LA BOLA NEGRA Review — A Massive Surprise
Lisa Johnson Mandell’s La Bola Negra review regrets that the stunning imagery and vision can’t quite stitch this patchwork quilt of a film together.
Well color me surprised! I entered my critics screening of La Bola Negra (The Black Ball) with the highest of expectations. It was a critical darling, having won top awards at the most prominent film festivals. The vision of Javier Calvo and Javier Ambrossi, the young, fresh, engaging and energetic Spanish writer-director duo, cheekily known as “Los Javis,” who created the sweeping epic couldn’t have been more promising.
And the trailer, giving us a tantalizing hint of the glorious visual elements that were to come, was mesmerizing.
Alas, after the first 10 minutes, during which a horrifying occurrence jolted us from our seats and served notice that this was going to be a consummately emotional heart wrencher, the narrative starts tangling and knotting, unraveling into a tangled (all be it beautiful) mess.
I fear that most filmgoers will be left befuddled, and wanting, spending more time trying to figure out “wait, what’s going on?” rather than enjoying the breathtaking imagery and internalizing the messages that are so earnestly and urgently presented.
A little more background, exposition or context of the events explored in the film would have been appreciated, as most non-Spanish viewers are not well versed on the intricacies of the Spanish Civil War and its cruel, homophobic fascists, or the works of Spanish poet playwright and theater director Federico García Lorca.
Hey, I spent a couple of the most seminal years of my life in Spain, can speak fluently with both a Castilian and Andalusian accent, am more familiar with the Spanish Civil War than most Americans, and have actually read and discussed some of Lorca’s poetry — in Spanish. Even I was confused by the narrative that whiplashes back and forth between three generations and time frames, the years 1932, 1937 and 2017.
Interestingly enough, one of those narratives uses the same device that enraged and confused so many viewers of the film Digger — there’s a distinct theatrical thread being pulled.
La Bola Negra review — stunt casting?
Perhaps in an effort to be more universally accessible, (which can sometimes be perceived as stunt casting), well known actors Penélope Cruz and Glenn Close were cast in a few brief slices of the film that clocks in at more than two-and-a-half hours. I found them to be memorable, but distracting and really rather out of place.
Spanish actors including Guitarricadelafuente, Miguel Bernardeau, Milo Quifes and Lola Dueñas give powerful performances, and give the film some much needed anchoring—but not enough.
There are countless dazzling images that reveal Los Javis as extremely visual filmmakers. There are moments so poignant they’re sure to wring tears from even the most stoic eyes. If only they could have been woven together in a more accessible fashion — this is a vibrant crazy quilt of a film, with a number of extraordinary patches rather arbitrarily stitched together, rather than a cohesive tapestry whose beauty is apparent to all who behold it.
I find it fascinating that over the last several years, Netflix has chosen three big swing, splashy Spanish language films to promote as Best Picture Academy Awards contenders: Roma, Emilia Perez and now La Bola Negra. Will this be the year Netflix takes the grand prize for its unique ambition?
At this point, La Bola Negra seems to have a lot of momentum, a number of critics claiming it shares a pedestal with The Odyssey.
I am obviously not one of those critics, but I do admire the effort, creativity and skill that went into the creation of La Bola Negra. I just want viewers to know that it may not be their cup of tea, and that confusion, frustration and melancholy could result. Be assured that it isn’t you, it’s them.
Rated R
2 Hours 37 Minutes
If this La Bola Negra review encourages you to storm the cineplex, find times and tickets at Fandango.com.
Lisa Johnson Mandell’s La Bola Negra review regrets that the stunning imagery and vision can’t quite stitch this patchwork quilt of a film together.